After ongoing media discussion around this, today the Milburn Review has been made public. As it is not an accessible document, we have tried to break down this response to tell you what is being proposed and what BDEF’s position is on it. We have focused on the impact of young Disabled people in our response.
Currently this review is only a recommendation and the Government hasn’t agreed yet to implement these recommendations.
However, it is widely expected that Andy Burnham and the Labour Party will accept these recommendations so the next step would be these changes going into legislation and then progressing to implementation. If this does go ahead, this will signify the largest change to work, education and welfare that the UK has ever seen.
The context
The Milburn Review proposes that there is around 1 million young people not in education, employment or training, sometimes called ‘NEETS’. The ambition in this review is to get to what the report calls ‘NEET Zero’ in 10 years, to drastically reduce youth unemployment from the current 13% to 5%.
The proposals
Benefits overhaul
Under-25s would no longer automatically receive the health-related top-up to Universal Credit or PIP, meaning some Disabled young people would receive less financial support. Higher support would remain for those assessed as facing the greatest barriers.
Youth Opportunity Service
Young people would get a named adviser and personalised plan bringing together employment, health and practical support. Those still NEET after 12 months, but considered able to work, would be guaranteed six months of paid employment.
Opportunity Guarantee
Young people would receive greater support into education, employment or training, including more apprenticeships, college places and subsidised jobs for people experiencing long-term unemployment.
Employer Incentives
£1 billion would incentivise employers to recruit young people, alongside recruitment expectations for public sector employers. Employers would receive £3,000 for recruiting someone NEET for six months, plus an additional £2,000 for young people facing greater barriers, including Disabled young people and care leavers.
Faster mental health support
Young people would be able to access support without having to wait for a formal diagnosis.
Youth opportunity test
Major government decisions would need to consider their impact on young people.
Education reform
Schools would have a greater responsibility to prepare young people for work, balancing academic learning with work experience and employment readiness.
BDEF's response
What we are seeing for young and older Disabled people in the UK is within the context of long-term austerity policies, COVID-19, inflation surge, worsening population health, the unprecedented double crisis of the NHS and social care (the latter being ignored for a long time by successive governments and increasing reliance on unpaid carers to meet the gaps), civil unrest, rising climate emergencies among many other events and situations.
While the Milburn Review acknowledges the breakdown in systems that have created the situation we are in, it misplaces responsibility for how we can improve the situation.
Age
Being a Disabled person does not begin or end at 25. Many Disabled people experience barriers throughout their lives, across education, employment, relationships, services, attitudes, stereotypes and the physical environment. Disabled young people become Disabled adults, so dividing support at age 25 feels arbitrary, discriminatory and does not reflect lived experience.
Benefits
Yet again there is a massive conflation happening with PIP. PIP is not an out of work benefit, it recognises that it costs more to be a Disabled person and meets that gap. The fact that a national review is once again conflating PIP with employment feels, if we are being generous, misguided and if we are being cynical, deliberate and discriminatory.
Education
Whilst we support a broadening of the curriculum to give pupils maximum choice in what they study, we have worries that pushing more statutory requirements onto already completely overloaded schools (who are at the forefront of the SEND crisis) will lead to a further lessening of necessary support and further drive the rate at which teachers are leaving the profession.
Employment
For over a decade, the Disability Employment Gap has remained at almost 30 percentage points, yet successive governments have failed to deliver a strategy capable of closing it. Existing schemes are not fit for purpose: Disability Confident has not been associated with better treatment, job satisfaction or mental health for Disabled workers (Hoque, 2024), while Access to Work applicants face average waits of 109 days (National Audit Office, 2026). Employers already do not meet their requirements under the Equality Act 2010 with reasonable adjustments and there is very minimal enforcement of this.
The bigger question is: where are the sustainable, accessible jobs? With 2.4 unemployed people for every vacancy, AI replacing lots of work roles, short-term incentives risk delaying rather than addressing the barriers Disabled people face.
BDEF members have already set out what employers need to do to make employment genuinely accessible in their open letter to employers, and a £5,000 incentive alone will not address these systemic barriers. The emphasis should be on changing workplaces, culture and work rather than penalising young Disabled people.
Mental health
We support improved and faster access to community mental health services for everyone. However, we want to know how this will be delivered. Mental Health services are already massively overcapacity and there are numerous access barriers for Disabled people when accessingMental Health services such as a lack of understanding or awareness of the complex Mental Health issues that align with people’s experiences of being a Disabled person.
Timms Review
Timms Review was set up to review PIP with Disabled people through Co-Production. Whilst there are questions as to whether this has actually happened, it seems really odd that a whole review into young people, a lot of whom are Disabled young people, has sidelined young Disabled people and older Disabled people (who were once young Disabled people) and decided their future without their involvement. It also is confusing that these two reviews are being run independently to each other considering the substantial overlap.
As an organisation that centres the experiences of Disabled people at its core, focusing on the barriers that Disabled people face in society, we are concerned that yet again the focus appears to be on reducing benefits rather than addressing the barriers that Disabled people face when accessing the employment market, both young and older. Even before we consider employment, the SEND crisis that is happening in schools is a massive contributing factor which changing the curriculum to be work focused alone won’t solve.
We do welcome changing the curriculum and both increased and speedier access to mental health services and support. However, similar to the feedback we co-created with our community to the Timms Report Evidence gathering, anything that is designed for Disabled people needs to be led by Disabled people as we know our experience best and the Milburn Review fails that very first test.
Penalising individuals does not get us any closer to solving an issue. Instead, the focus should be on tackling the barriers Disabled people face to being heard, valued and connected, with the independence, choice and control to shape our lives and lead change in our communities.
We will be watching very closely as to what decisions are made in response to this review and the impact this will have on our community. We will be writing to the relevant people.
If you're considering contacting your MP, a parliamentary committee or the Equality and Human Rights Commission, you can find templates below.